Temporary support orders

A temporary support order is simply a way of resolving a couple’s financial  issues until a final decree is issued. Sounds simple, doesn’t it.

However, in my case, I was ordered to pay 90% of my net income to my spouse with no way to appeal the order. This went on for over a year. How did this situation arise?

First, a trial judge has almost complete discretion over temporary support orders – he or she can order virtually anything. There is no appeal until after the final decree is signed (which, in my case, is still unsigned at the time of writing – over 2.5 years since first filing for divorce).

Both parties typically file an affidavit of financial condition (an AFC) stating their income and assets. The judge must then determine what will best preserve the community assets while keeping the family as close as possible to their “accustomed” lifestyle. Any support orders are nominally based on “need and ability to pay”.

In my case, I left the house a few months after filing my complaint for divorce because her verbal abuse had become intolerable. Most men end up leaving either voluntarily or involuntarily (via a TRO or temporary restraining order – see this post).

This enabled my wife’s lawyer to file for “exclusive possession” basically making her a tenant and making it illegal for me to enter my own property (i.e. becoming a trespasser). This the judge granted.

I was then ordered to pay the mortgage and utilities on the house (amounting to $3000 per month) even though I was paying to rent a room somewhere else. Ironically, I was renting a room on my six figure salary to minimize expenses – the judge used my low rent to justify that I could pay more to support my previous household. 

I was also ordered to pay $1400 in child support for my two children (even though child support was supposed to include a housing element- so what I was paying for the house should have been taken into account).

So basically, this took my support payments to 90% of my regular net income. The judge thought that two extra jobs that I did in the summer and winter should be added to my income when determining how much I could afford to pay. Nevermind that I only received two lump sum payments in the summer and winter and only IF I was offered the work – which was not guaranteed. Even with this extra income the support payments amounted to around 78% of my net income.

The judge also ordered my wife to list the house for sale but having all the bills paid gave her little incentive to sell. She repeatedly cancelled buyer appointments and kept the house is poor condition to deter buyers. She also refused to lower the price without a court order (which takes 1-2 months to obtain). Without the ability to enter the property I could not even tidy up before a buyer inspection.

Temporary support orders can be modified. All attempts to modify my support payments were rejected by the judge – even AFTER my wife got a full-time job!

Lessons Learned:

If you plan to get divorced avoid earning extra income for three years prior (so your ability to pay is less).

Demand that your wife gets a job (so her need for support is less)

If possible, sell your house and start renting before the divorce – so you don’t get stuck with a house you can’t sell or get kicked out.

Assume you will be kicked out of your own home – move your possessions to a private storage before you file for divorce.

When you move out, rent a place at least equal in value to the one you left. Your obligations will reduce your “ability to pay”.

FINAL OBSERVATIONS

1. I had read about the hard ball tactics above before filing for divorce and assumed I didn’t need them because I had a signed and notarized separation agreement that outlined all settlement terms in case of divorce.

2. The judge has never ruled on the separation agreement nor did she base her temporary support orders on the agreement (which provided for support payments of $1800 and gave me possession of the house, cars, and all assets in exchange for a $100,000 lump sum payment). Thus, my agreement was completely useless.

Don’t assume it can’t happen to you and follow the lessons above!

Advertisements

7 Responses to Temporary support orders

  1. Matt Linder says:

    We all make dumb decisions like getting married! If my divorce has taught me one thing, that is there is NO woman on the planet worth marriage! The law is on their side only, a man has no rights in divorce. There is nothing a man gets out of marriage that he can not get being single! The little tiny tax break you get from filing jointly cant even come close to what you will pay when you get a divorce!

  2. […] of the marital residence. After all, possession is 9/10ths of the law. If you read my post on temporary support orders  you can see that a judge can order a guy to pay all the bills on a house he does not live in for […]

  3. Robin 2005 says:

    Hum ok well maybe in your case father’s have rights! In mine mother’s should also! I have a long story to tell you men out there that feel you have been mistreated. I was married for 12 years and no sooner after that he cheated on me. I had worked for 6 years at Vons and made 3 times more money than my husband. We had our 1st daughter and I wanted to stay home with her and I did. Four years later we had our 2nd daughter and started working when she was 1. About 4 years later my grandma became ill and needed full time care and I quit my job. And that was the time my husband of 12 years cheated. I kicked him out and went and got a divorse. But the jugde didn’t care that I had no car and no high school diplomia. And that I was working 2 jobs and going to cake decorating school to better my chances on a higher salary. I was ordered to work 40 hours no matter what. So you men that think you have had it bad , well its not just you. I walked and so did my poor girls ever where and some how we made it. Until now I guess he thinks that I should pay him back all the spousal support from 2004 till now after we had talked and agreed that I could keep it. I told him that I remarried right after I got married and 2 weeks after that I gave him the money back. In fact every 2 weeks for 9 months till I asked him if I could keep it since I had been drivng our girls so far to school every day. It was only 125 a month not much to really wink about. You know if it were up to me if someone chooese to cheat they should have to pay that for the rest of there lives but then again thats just me……………………………………………………………………….

  4. […] she likes) on issues like alimony (see here and here), custody/visitation, attorney fees, and temporary support orders. Possibly related posts: (automatically generated)Best State for Divorce?Is Marriage a […]

  5. zynga poker cheat…

    […]Temporary support orders « Anatomy of a Divorce[…]…

  6. Jake says:

    Holy cow – I thought I’d seen it all. Work less so your ability to pay is less? Make your wife work a job so your liability is less? No wonder you are divorced – not a clue what it means to be married and in a partnership. Me, me, me, I, I, I.

    Really classy. Not.

  7. Leslie says:

    I paid the house payment over for a year so he could refinance the house he can’t get a loan because he has a score of 550 he does not pay his bills but won’t sign off on putting the house on the market there is people out here that arent horrible oh did I mention he drank and tried to break in the house while he was drunk

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: